Ottomanelli Butcher Shoppe Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing Ottomanelli Butcher Shoppe, a historic neighborhood fixture in Yorkville, NYC. Known for quality meats, homemade salads, bolognese, and prepared foods. The family-owned business offers a wide variety of starters like fresh mozzarella with roasted peppers and soups like steakhouse chili. Their sandwiches, including the Italian combo, are highly recommended. Customers praise the excellent quality and service, with some mentioning the old-school charm of the shop. The butcher shop also offers a selection of salads, sandwiches, and prepared foods, with special made-to-order options available. With over 100 years in business, Ottomanelli Butcher Shoppe is a must-visit for those seeking fresh, quality meats and a taste of history.
Starters
Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers
over wild greens with a balsamic glaze.
Mozzarella In Carrozza
crispy coated mozzarella cheese with marinara sauce.
Caprese Salad
fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, with a balsamic vinaigrette.
Popcorn Shrimp
over seasonal greens.
Marinated Grilled Calamari
with your choice of or marinara sauce.
Soup Of The Day
served with garlic bread.
Our Own Steakhouse Chili
served with garlic bread.
Soups
Salads
House Salad
lettuce, radicchio, cucumber and red onions with a balsamic vinaigrette.
Chopped Salad
endive, radicchio, crumbled bleu cheese, tomatoes, parsley, granny smith apples and shallot vinaigrette.
Classic Caesar
romaine hearts, parmesan cheese, crispy croutons and zesty dressing add grilled chicken or popcorn shrimp. add $2.00
Grilled Chicken Pecan Salad
seasonal mixed greens, goat cheese, toasted pecans, walnuts and dried cranberries with a honey citrus vinaigrette.
Catch Of The Day
(monday)
Texas Style Bbq Ribs
(tuesday)
Cowboy Cut Prime Rib Steak
bone in grilled to your liking. (wednesday)
Mystery Night
(thursday)
Our Specials
Pasta
Penne Con Quattro Formaggio
with grilled chicken in a four cheese cream sauce
Penne Alla Romana
sauteed chicken, sun dried tomatoes, mushrooms and string beans in garlic and oil.
Spaghetti With Chicken
sauteed chicken and spinach in a garlic and while wine butter sauce.
Angelica's Spaghetti With Meatballs
Spaghetti Napolitano
with calamari, shrimp and scallops in a fra diavolo sauce.
Fusilli Mozzarella
with roasted eggplant, mushrooms and fresh mozzarella in a plum tomato sauce.
Chicken Parmigiana
served over spaghetti
Chicken Gorgonzola
with roasted red peppers in a gorgonzola cream sauce.
Chicken Paillard
grilled chicken breast marinated in fresh lemon juice, extra virgin olive oil and fresh herbs.
Chicken Franchese
sauteed chicken breast in a white wine and butter sauce.
Chicken Florentine
sauteed chicken breast topped with spinach and mozzarella in a marsala mushroom sauce.
Sauteed Blackened Chicken
sauteed chicken breast in a blackened spice.
Panko Chicken
succulent chicken breast tossed in a parmesan bread crumb blend, fried to a golden brown and served over marinara sauce pasta on the side.
Chicken
Otto's Prime Time
16 Oz. Prime N.y. Strip Steak
Dr. Eric's Hanger Steak
marinated in red wine, fresh herbs and a hint of soy sauce.
Lamb Chops
three baby rib lamb chops with great natural flavors served with mint jelly.
Our Famous 1/2 Lb. Steak Burger
prime sirloin ground fresh daily at our own prime meat shoppe, served on a toasted brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle.
Dress Up Your Steak Burger
american, swiss, cheddar, provolone, mozzarella, feta, bleu, goat, crispy onions or coleslaw add $1.00. bacon, roasted peppers, sherried mushrooms, chili or olive tapenade add $1.50. crispy waffle fries add $1.75.
Our Own Off The Grill Steak Burgers
House Specialty Steak Burgers
New Orleans
popcorn shrimp and spicy cajun remoulade.
The Sicilian
fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and basil pesto.
The Carolina
coleslaw, swiss and bbq sauce.
V.i.p. Burger
mushrooms, grilled onions and provolone.
Wisconsin
cheddar and smoked bacon.
Super Three Cheese
swiss, american, and mozzarella.
Popeye
spinach and mozzarella.
Turkey Burger
with our own cranberry ketchup.
Coffee
(regular or decaf)
Harney Teas
(assorted)
Poland Spring Water
Coke, Diet Coke
Snapple
(assorted)